Donnetta Trawick has a hearty laugh that fills a room.

With that laugh, she explained how she first met Dwight Townes when they both worked at the Pilgrim's processing plant in Timberville.

“We met over chicken,” Trawick said.

For Townes, food had always been a common thread in his tumultuous life.

His mother was murdered when he was only 6 years old. As an adult, he said, he fell into addiction.

Originally from Trenton, N.J., Townes moved to Virginia nearly a decade ago for a new start.

While working at Pilgrim's, Townes dared to dream about opening a barbecue business of his own. When Trawick heard it, she said, she was all-in on helping him make it happen.

Selling barbecued chicken at the Broadway Farmers Market, a business was born in early 2020.

Townes cooked all the food, while Trawick talked with customers and did the marketing.

“She’s the brains of the operation. She has really brought this whole thing to life,” Townes said.

Returning each week with bigger and bigger grills that could cook more chicken, the operation quickly grew to meet demand.

With the end of the season approaching and a booming business, Townes knew he wanted to open a year-round spot.

Townes and Trawick found a small 16-by-10-foot shack on North Congress Street in New Market in October of 2020. While in New Market, Townes Homemade BBQ's menu expanded from only chicken to three kinds of barbecued meats.

When people requested new foods, the menu continued to expand, adding popular side dishes like macaroni and cheese.

“We were like, ‘Yeah, we could do that,’ so we added it,” Trawick said.

Wanting even more space, Townes Homemade BBQ changed its location to a spot on South Main Street in Broadway, near the Virginia Poultry Growers Cooperative feed mill.

The new location opened on Aug. 1.

With a background in media arts, Trawick decorated the new spot with corrugated metal sheets, paper banners and brown-stained wood accents.

The walls also feature detailed photography of the restaurant’s meats, sauces and dishes that she took.

Trawick said all the items on the menu are popular. She and Townes agreed the Jamaican jerk chicken is a standout.

The jerk chicken is smoked with hickory, red oak and cherry wood. It’s served with golden rice pilaf made with sazón, a spice mix.

The chicken is topped with cilantro and Townes’ spicy jerk sauce.

Townes said the sauce recipe wasn’t successful until they found their key ingredient: Jamaican allspice. Using freshly ground pimento berries, the spice gives the dish an authentic feel.

The chicken platter is served with traditional coco bread. Made with coconut milk, the pillowy bread is similar to Korean bao buns or a sweet Hawaiian roll.

Julie Jones, a resident of Broadway, said she eats Townes Homemade BBQ at least once a month.

She said the jerk chicken is delicious, but her favorite is the barbecued pork served with Townes’ original sauce.

“Their smoked meats and really special and the sauces he makes are just top notch,” Jones said.

Townes only offers one kind of barbecue sauce, which is based on a recipe started by his grandfather.

Townes said he spent at least six years transforming that recipe into his own blend.

“Nobody can copy that sauce. You can try, but you can’t copy it,” Townes said.

The sauce doesn’t hail from any one particular barbecue tradition. Sweet and tangy with savory and rich tomato, Townes said you won’t find sauce like his anywhere.

“It has five to seven different herbs in it. It has a little bit of Carolinas in it, it has a little bit of this, but it’s mine,” Townes said.

Trawick said the entire menu is the same way. It doesn’t follow any single barbecue tradition, but draws on styles that originated in Kansas City, North Carolina and Virginia for a taste all its own.

“[We’re] not trying to make Jamaican like Jamaicans, [we’re] not trying to make barbecue sauce like a down South [or] a Virginia style,” Trawick said. “We’re not like [any other style].”

Everything is made from scratch, and Trawick said they only use the best ingredients they can get.

The restaurant’s banana pudding is made from real separated eggs, blended to a creamy, almost whipped texture. There’s a soft crunch from crushed vanilla wafer cookies and smooth banana flavor.

Trawick said she took her natural place as the manager of the business and the front of house manager.

“She makes you feel like she’s known you her whole life,” Jones said. “I’ve gone in last minute hoping to get a meal for unexpected company, and she’s come through for me.”

The couple-turned-business team has big plans for the space they’re settling into.

Soon, they’ll be bottling Townes Homemade BBQ and the Jamaican jerk sauce for retail sale.

In the restaurant’s unfinished outdoor space, they said they’ll be adding an outdoor kitchen, a patio space, more signage and making improvements to the parking lot.

Townes and Trawick want to start serving breakfast and fried ice cream made from a secret recipe. Those items have to wait until the restaurant installs a new hood system in the indoor kitchen.

Jones said the restaurant is a "great addition to the community."

“It’s an easy stop in and out," she said. "It’s been a lot of different businesses, but I’m happy he’s there and I hope [Townes] stays a long time."

Contact Jillian Lynch at 574-6274 or Follow Jillian on Twitter @lynchjillian_

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.