I learned a lot about how to die from my mother, and long before I was holding her hand as she drew her last breath.

After nearly two decades as a nurse’s aide, Mom became a hospice home-care worker. She took care of the dying, one patient at a time. She spent eight to 10 hours a day with them, sometimes for many months. As her colleagues told me at her wake, when Janey Schultz showed up, people lived longer.

Regularly, my mother and I talked about what she was learning about the end of life.

It’s not uncommon, for example, for the terminally ill to express last wishes. Some of her patients wanted to eat food made from family recipes. Or smell their favorite perfume one more time on their wrists. One of her patients loved listening to songs that were popular when she fell in love with her husband, who had been gone for nearly two decades.

Many patients wanted to have final conversations with the people in their lives. They wanted to make apologies or welcome others’ confessions; they wanted to reminisce. Often, they hoped to see the best parts of themselves reflected in the loving gaze of others.

My mother never offered specifics, but she would talk about how often those who are dying wanted to share stories from their lives. “It’s as if they want to know that it all mattered,” my mother once told me. “It’s my job to make sure they know it did.”

I learned a lot from listening to my mother’s stories, and I went on to write about issues of death and dying for more than 20 years. I have interviewed so many patients in their last days. I have sat quietly in a corner as loved ones said goodbye, and spent weeks — in one case, a year — with those left to grieve.

The biggest takeaway, for me: There is no substitute for love in a person’s final days — for the dying and for those who are left behind. I’ve witnessed how the gentle presence of family and friends can calm the most frightened hearts and help to relieve suffering. I have seen the grace that can come from knowing you did all that you could in the final days for someone you loved.

The coronavirus has changed how people are allowed to die and how loved ones are permitted to grieve. More than 192,000 people have died of COVID-19 in this country, and except for the tending of heroic health care workers, most of them died alone. Many of them had been separated from everyone they love for weeks before they died. The death toll does not include those who died from other causes but were also isolated from loved ones because of COVID-19 precautions.

Hundreds of thousands of people in the country are now grieving, without any of the usual supports to get them through. No funerals or wakes; no in-person visits from friends, loved ones or spiritual counselors. No memories, either, of how they did all that they could, because we could not let them. They could not care for their loved ones in this time of their greatest need. They could not even hold their hands or whisper in their ears. Anyone who has ever loved another person can surely imagine the weight of this loss.

Last week, we’ve learned that, as early as February, President Donald Trump told journalist Bob Woodward that he knew how dangerous the virus was but played it down in public. We are only learning this now because Woodward waited to tell us until he was on the brink of releasing his new book about Trump. He has 18 interviews on tape.

Trump is now claiming that he was trying to prevent a national panic, which maybe someone somewhere might be willing to believe if he weren’t constantly making up the darkest scenarios of what awaits us if Joe Biden is elected president. “If I don’t win,” Trump tweeted, “America’s Suburbs will be OVERRUN with Low Income Projects, Anarchists, Agitators, Looters and, of course, ‘Friendly Protesters.’”

Sure, he just wants us to stay calm.

Journalists are debating whether Woodward should have let the public know when he knew the president was willfully endangering countless Americans. Could Woodward have saved lives? Is it his job to do so? We’ll be discussing this in ethics classes around the country, including in mine.

Perhaps for some of us, in the wake of these revelations, this is just an intellectual exercise. A debate. Lucky, oblivious us.

We can’t un-die people. For every person who has lost a loved one to this deadly virus, the question looms: Could my loved one have lived?

(8) comments


And the hits just keep on coming: Olivia Troye, who was an advisor for Pence for two years (on the coronavirus, among other things) announced she was going to vote for Biden, because Trump's coronavirus response was focused primarily on politics and reelection, showing a “flat out disregard for human life”.


Waaaaaa...its all Trumps fault.....my god are you people really that screwed up? The whole story was for one reason and one reason alone to attack president Trump...so disgusting!


Bingo. Any sympathy I had for her initially over losing her mother quickly evaporated with her last paragraphs.


That was lovely until you launched into the Trump deranged screed.

Which kind of negated everything else you wrote.



True dat.




Punching her progressive ticket...


Actually, Connie, your anger is misguided. The reason that those in hospitals and on hospice can't see their loved ones is not because of President Trump, or because of The Chinese Flu, but because of the panic purposely instilled by Demokkkrats who are attempting to shut down the economy in order to defeat President Trump. President Trump acted decisively early on to mitigate the negative effects of The Chinese Flu by shutting down flights from China and from Europe, for which the Demokkkrats called him a racist and a xenophobe. Even Demokkkrats, though, have had to backpedal, and begrudgingly acknowledge that his decision was the right one, and saved countless thousands of lives. As for President Trump's comments to Woodward, he did the right thing once again by avoiding panic and remaining calm while at the same time, taking the Chinese Virus seriously. That's what mature leaders do. With respect to President Trump's comments concerning Creepy Joe Biden and the fact that if Biden is elected, the entire country will look like Portland, Los Angeles, Chicago, and New York, that is simple truth telling. Demokkkrats have announced their intentions to defund the police, strip away the second amendment from our constitution so that law abiding citizens can't protect themselves, and have thrown in with Antifa and Black Lives Matter, two violent, wicked, Marxist organizations intent on the total destruction of The United States. I thank God every day for President Trump. He is the best president of my lifetime.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.